Wednesday, June 19, 2013

"The wealth effect isn't what it used to be." Hallelujah!!

The Washington Post's Robert Samuelson, in his June 16th column, wrote:
The “wealth effect” isn’t what it used to be. For those who have forgotten, this refers to households’ tendency to spend some part of their increased real estate and stock market wealth and thereby boost the economy. During the boom years, Americans borrowed lavishly against rapidly appreciating home values. One Federal Reserve study estimated the extra cash at $700 billion annually from 2001 to 2005. Now psychology has changed. Careless optimism has given way to stubborn cautiousness. Wealth gains don’t translate into similar amounts of higher spending.

The gist of what follows is that, having experienced the Great Recession, folks are of the mind that "lavishly" spending their equity leads to, well, great recessions. And that awareness somehow presents a challenging backdrop for the economy, or at least for the Fed, going forward.

His final two paragraphs:
There has been a stunning shift in behavior, notes Zandi. In 2006, at the peak of the housing boom, almost 90 percent of homeowners who were refinancing mortgages increased the size of their loan, according to data from Freddie Mac; they were borrowing against higher housing values. In 2012, 83 percent of refinancing homeowners either didn’t change the mortgage amount or lowered it. They were striving to pay off debt.

So the wealth effect varies by time and circumstances. Now it is a casualty of the financial crisis and Great Recession. We have yet another example of risk aversion dominating the economy. People eager to borrow have faith in the future; people eager to repay debts worry about the future. We are prisoners of psychology, which can change but is hard to manipulate. That is the predicament for policy and politics.

Now think about it; leading up to the recession, folks were cashing in their equity and spending galore, and, somehow, the fact that they're acting in what in their 2013 view they deem responsibly presents a political predicament? Hmm... The consumer, for the moment, apparently understands what policymakers do not; that economic success comes from saving and spending wisely. The fact that real world experience makes for a consumer who is hard for sheltered academics to manipulate should be music to our ears!

Saturday, June 15, 2013

Craftiness into crapiness...

Here's an explanation of how stock market volatility can be caused by factors other than the factors you and I consider when buying stocks for the long-term. And yet another reason to never ever attempt to time the market:

The new Japanese prime minister has vowed to manipulate the yen into the cellar to promote an export-driven economic boom (somehow that's criminal when China allegedly does it, but a-okay when Japan and the U.S. do it). Believing he just might pull it off, let's say you---the ever-crafty trader---decide to exploit an "obvious" opportunity: So you borrow, say, a million yen from a Japanese bank, convert that to ten thousand U.S. dollars (I'm rounding) and buy an S&P 500 index fund.

Here's what you're BETTING on:

For starters, let's say the dividend on the index fund amounts to 2.0%, while the interest rate on the Japanese bank loan is 0.15%---you're thus making nice money right from the get-go. In fact---given that you're investing borrowed money (your cost is just the interest on the loan)---you're making an absolute killing!

And if the U.S. stock market advances while you're in this trade you could be making a killing of a killing.

Example: You hold the trade for a year, the S&P fund nets you a 10% return, your fund is now worth $11,000. You pay back the yen-denominated loan which, in U.S. dollars, amounts to $10,015. That's a cool $985 profit, piece a cake! A huge piece a cake!

Now the real kicker: This is where your craftiness comes in. Remember, the Japanese have vowed to devalue the yen, so let's pretend they succeed to the tune of 20% over the course of a year. Which means that it would no longer take 100 yen to make a dollar, it would take 120. Which means that you only need $8,333 to pay off your million yen loan. Which means there's an extra cool $1,667 added to your $985. Now we're talking an utterly monster rate of return.

Now the BIG BUT! But, if, as has been the case of late, the yen, for whatever reasons (rising interest rates perhaps), defies the central planners and actually appreciates against the U.S. dollar, your craftiness soon turns into utter crapiness. You don't make a killing, you get killed.

Example: You're in the above-referenced trade, the yen spikes, say, 20% against the dollar (to 80/dollar). It now takes $12,500, plus the pittance in interest, to pay off the million yen loan. But you only have $10,000 (or so you thought) in your index fund, which means you're out a (relative to the size of your scheme) big chunk of money. Oh, but it's much worse than you thought; you, alas, weren't the only big-betting-bloke out there. Carry trades are the addiction of hedge fund geniuses, and, I assure you, they carried out that scheme to the tune of billions. And they're much quicker, and much more resourceful, than you. They stormed the gates (out of the dollar [denominated stocks] and back to the yen) when it gained only 5%, which of course exacerbated the rise in the yen, and---UH OH!---a decline in U.S. stocks. Now you're really screwed; your $10,000 is worth $8,000 and you owe $12,500, and you're not Long Term Capital Management and there's no Alan Greenspan to (despicably) come bail you out (which is a whole other discussion on moral hazard): Read Don't Worry My Child, I'll Buy You a New One...

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Dancing under a cloudless sky - Or - Gladys's QB - Or - Old habits die hard...

Being a committed rain dancer (rain dances always worked because the natives never stopped dancing till it started raining), I maintain that the Fed's buying up of $85 billion a month of treasury notes and mortgage-backed securities can't be a good thing. And I am increasingly in the minority.

Clearly, to date, the inflation hawks (the "experts" who promised that an expanding Fed balance sheet means ever-growing inflation), had it wrong (operative words being "to date"). The thing about inflation being a monetary phenomenon, a la M. Friedman, is that the money has to be doing something: As I stated in Little Chasing Going On, all that new money continues to do nothing in bank excess reserve accounts.

We can speculate on what the Fed governors are thinking: how it appears as though they're not at all interested in seeing those trillions make their way into the economy---not while they're paying the banks interest on those excess reserves---but that's not my message for today. Today I'm going to take a shot at those who, on one hand, shout for free-markets while, on the other, lobby for more QE. That---to name just two---would be the likes of CNBC's Larry Kudlow and The American Enterprise Institute's James Pethokoukis (I like them both btw), who apparently view the White House-appointed Ben Bernanke's intervention into the marketplace vastly different than they do that of his (re)appointer.

So why fret when free-marketers, like the aforementioned gents, support this Fed intervention? I mean how does the simple exchanging of cash (that'll do nothing in bank excess reserve accounts) for bonds (that [presumably] would've done nothing on bank balance sheets) impose on the "free market"? Well, for starters, we're talking about an "investor" (the Fed) buying up the supply of an asset with no personal profit motive. And while forcing up the price (and down the yield) of bonds, the Fed is forcing those who normally would have invested in said bonds (like retired folks) to look elsewhere for yield (which, by itself, is a QE objective). And, let me be clear, "elsewhere" can be a very risky place.

I'd like to remind those self-proclaimed free-market types that there's a reason we call the bond market the bond "market". That's right, "market"; the place where buyers and sellers come to transact. Where, when we're talking bonds, those seeking capital compete on terms and their credit ratings for the investment business of those seeking a (generally safe) rate of return---and, as well, where the holders of existing bonds sell to willing buyers. When the government (yeah, let's here call the Fed "government"), spending newly "printed", or other people's, money (not being the least bit concerned with return) enters the "market"; whether it be the market for mid-western grown beef, corn, solar power, residential real estate or bonds, pricing---as I suggest above---becomes profoundly, and dangerously, distorted.

The free-market/small-government/big-QE advocates' most glaring contradiction is their railing against the seemingly unbridled growth of government while pushing for yet more QE. Do they not understand how the Fed, by scooping up trillions in treasury notes, and thereby suppressing interest rates, is directly facilitating our policymakers' thriftlessness? With rates this low, why the hell not borrow out the wazoo? My goodness!! Can they not foresee what will happen (as I'll explain below) when God knows how many trillions in debt begins to rollover amid future budget deficits and inevitably higher interest rates? Do they not understand that bigger government begets bigger government---that a growing public sector begets a shrinking private sector?

You gotta love how Bernanke calms the market by proclaiming that they'll unwind their titanic balance sheet without sparking the mother of all bond sell-offs. He says they can choose to simply allow those notes to roll off at maturity. Well, now, let's think about that: Let's say that a hundred billion in treasury notes is maturing, say, tomorrow. That means the Treasury must pony up a hundred billion dollars. Of course it ain't got a hundred billion dollars, so it must, yes, borrow to pay back what it borrowed. Do you think for a microsecond that the Fed (today's Fed anyway), after facilitating the borrowing of trillions at crazy-low interest rates, is going to subject the Treasury to the real world, and, consequently, the taxpayer to higher taxes? Not on your life their careers! They'll subject us to ever-higher inflation instead.

Ever-higher inflation? But the last few years have proven, a la Kudlow, that QE doesn't equate to rising inflation, so am I not thus dancing under a cloudless sky? Well, not ultimately. You see, in my never-ending QE scenario the Fed continues to facilitate utterly wasteful government spending (the notion that government spending [largely] equals waste is something virtually all free-market types agree on), which means that even if banks remain willing to buy from the treasury then sell to the Fed for newly "printed" dollars (that remain idle in excess reserve accounts), resources---through government spending wasting---are declining faster than the money supply: That's inflation.

Here's the analogy I used in Leaving Liberty? (forgive the shameless plug):
If you and five others are stranded on a desert island and you have a granola bar for sale, what’s it worth? If your famished fellow castaways have one dollar among them, it’s worth a dollar. If they have ten, it’s worth ten. Now, you tell me, when we print trillions, what ultimately happens to the prices of gas and granola? As Milton Friedman said, “Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.” But what if the castaways have ten dollars and you happen to have two granola bars? Well then, they’re worth five each. Then, if a chimp steals and eats one, the remaining one, experiencing 100 percent inflation, is worth ten. Now wouldn’t that be a supply disruption, as opposed to a monetary phenomenon? Yes, that would be a supply disruption, and a monetary phenomenon. In that the supply of money did indeed increase—on a per-unit basis.

Gladys's QB

Gladys, my assistant, stepped into my office yesterday morning and asked how I control my sugar intake. I said "what's up?", she said "my doctor says I have to cut down on sugar, but I don't put sugar on anything!" So I pulled up a website featuring the glycemic index and explained how certain foods, once in the body, will spike a person's blood sugar. Gladys was none too happy to discover that she needed to give up, among other things, bananas (for a moment I thought she was going to cry). Now Gladys is the picture of 65 year-old health. In fact clients are forever shocked to find out she's medicare eligible. So, from the outside, there's absolutely no evidence that her QB (quantity of bananas) is doing her any harm whatsoever. And, besides, she loves them and justifies extending QB because she thinks she needs more potassium. My advice was to stop the QB cold turkey, find a healthier potassium source, suffer through her cravings, and get her body back to its normal insulin production.

(Note: I just asked Gladys for permission to include the above and all she could talk about was how much she loves bananas. She was, again, on the verge of tears.)

My advice to the Fed is to stop QE cold turkey, allow the economy to suffer withdrawals and adjust accordingly (which it will), and find its way to healthy free-market productivity. Yes, I know, the distinguished Kudlows and Pethokoukises would tell me I'm crazy; that the markets would freak and we'd be right back in recession. And they could very well be correct. But I say, whatever it takes, and the sooner the better! We do not want to be sitting here years hence with a trashed dollar and a huge deficit, while bonds are maturing left and right. But don't hold your breath, for---as Gladys will attest---old habits are very hard to break.

"Free-market capitalism is the best path to prosperity" Lawrence Kudlow

Monday, June 10, 2013

I like dem earnings...

During a portfolio review meeting this morning, my client told of a financial program he recently watched that featured a concerned analyst describing how the quality of corporate earnings are currently suspect --- given that they have largely been achieved through cost-cutting. In the analyst's view, companies are just doing business down the same old channels, while hoarding huge cash positions, and that doesn't bode well for the stock market going forward.

Now let me ask you, at what point would you rather commit your hard-earned money to stocks; when companies are in the throes of expansion, allocating capital, adding to labor, reaching into other markets, etc., or at a point where they've survived the worst recession since the Great Depression, purged their excesses, paid down their debt and have, consequently, experienced impressive growth in their margins --- that is, when they're cash-rich and poised to intelligently exploit future opportunities? In other words, would you prefer to enter during an expansion, not knowing at what stage it's in, or before one gets started (one, that is, greater than the sub-2% rate we're currently experiencing)?

Personally, I'd choose the latter, which, I caution, is not to suggest that I believe the next great expansion---or, for that matter, the next great contraction---awaits around the next calendar quarter. I make no predictions. My point is simply that, while I only advocate long-term thinking when it comes to stocks, I like what I'm presently hearing with regard to prudence among CEOs. However, I don't like what I'm presently seeing with regard to imprudence among policymakers, which---healthy balance sheets notwithstanding---could do a real number on stock prices.

Stay tuned...

Saturday, June 8, 2013

Let's not waste our time on the impossible...

Fareed Zakaria closes last Wednesday's column titled China is not the World's Other Superpower with the following:
The United States should seek good and deep relations with China. They would mean a more stable, prosperous and peaceful world. Further integrating China into an open global system would help maintain that system and the open world economy that rests on it. But this can happen only if China recognizes and respects that system and operates from the perspective of a global power and not that of a “narrow-minded” state seeking only to maximize its interests.

Yeah, okay, but to suggest that China should not act solely in its self interest is not only unrealistic, it's impossible. Every governing body, as does every individual, acts in its own self interest. It's all about what "it" believes its self interest to be. As our "leaders", for example, impose their values onto other nations---while they profess they're acting in the interest of humanity---they are indeed acting in what they believe to be our their self interest: There are many pockets remaining in the world that are utterly rife with all manner of human rights violations, but, as you've noticed, our "leaders" are very selective in terms of at whom they direct their influence.

Rather than encourage the impossible, we would be far better served by leading by example. And the very best way---counterintuitive as it may seem---would be to adopt an entirely unilateral free trade policy. That is, tell the world that we welcome into our market absolutely anything and everything it can produce --- no restrictions whatsoever. And if nations such as China wish to maintain barriers between our products and their citizens---if they want to limit their people's access to the world market---that's entirely their business.

Sound crazy? Now think about it; a country cannot engage with such a healthy-thinking trading partner without, to a great degree, emulating it. You see, we buy with U.S. dollars, which are, in the end, claims against U.S. goods, services and assets. When, for example, the Chinese exchange stuff they make for U.S. dollars, they must ultimately buy from, or invest in, the U.S --- or they'll buy from, or invest in, another country whose citizens desire to buy from, or invest in, the U.S. All the while the American economy benefits greatly: As we buy the stuff we desire at world prices, we are left with greater resources with which to expand (and invent) areas where we enjoy a comparative advantage. The fact that the rest of the world yet so thirsts for U.S. dollars tells us that such areas presently exist. To keep it so, we must adamantly resist any policies that would limit our access to world markets. Same goes for policies that would hinder our producers capacity for production: I.e., when we legislate greater costs onto U.S. industry, make no mistake, we jeopardize the economic future (less production, less global demand for the U.S. dollar, higher prices of goods and services, fewer job opportunities) of the very people voters the crafters of those policies pretend to help.