Saturday, July 20, 2013

Where true free-trade exists (and videos)

There is a place where true free-trade exists. Where individuals transact across borders as freely as they transact across a city street. We call this place the United States. The Constitution (Art. 1 Sec. 10) forbids protectionism between the states.

Interesting... So the founding fathers were concerned that political boundaries (lines seen only on maps) in the U.S. could somehow be used to erect barriers to trade; that politicians might collude with businesses (and trade unions) to limit their residents' freedom to enjoy the produce of other states. Thank God, with regard to interstate commerce, they were thinking!

"Trade deficits" abound within the U.S.: Alaskans eagerly import all the California fruit, nuts, technology and entertainment they can consume, while Californians have minuscule (by comparison) interest in the stuffs produced in Alaska---and nobody gives it a second thought.

Fascinating! Where the freedom to transact across borders is entirely unfettered no one makes a stink about trade imbalances. Why? Because we know intuitively that to engage such nonsense would (at best) benefit special interest groups at the expense of the everyone else.

So why then do we betray our intuition when it comes to international commerce? Why do we view exchanging the initial result of our productive efforts (U.S. dollars) for the product of (for example) a Chinese company at all differently than we do an Alaskan exchanging with a Californian? Well, "we" either desire protection for our particular industry or we are pawns of the colluders mentioned above.

Here, once again, is how that happens:





Thursday, July 18, 2013

Pretense of commitment to limited government...

Okay, so I was right, dang it! Although, predicting Bernanke's tone before Congress, that is, anticipating dovishness from the ultimate dove, does not a guru make.

As I watched just a bit of yesterday's Q and A, I thought to myself "I should've predicted the line of questioning coming from our distinguished lawmakers." Although, predicting the accolades from the left and the accusations from the right, that is, anticipating partisan BS from a bunch of partisan BSers, is the ultimate no brainer.

What I found most amusing was the manner in which the various actors addressed the good professor. Republican Jeb Hensarling looked down his nose at (and questioned) Bernanke in the most condescending fashion. Although, I must say, after just Googling his voting record, Hensarling---unlike a number of his colleagues on the right---indeed voted nay on the various Keynesian stimulus efforts imposed onto the taxpayer by the Obama administration. Although, he did vote yea on all the Keynesian stimulus efforts imposed onto the taxpayer by the previous (G.W. Bush) administration. As for the Democrats, they lauded Bernanke as the savior (from the next Great Depression) of the free world. Now they would be the Democrats who (without going to the trouble of Googling, so you'll correct me if I'm wrong) voted yea for Keynesianism under Obama and nay for the same under Bush.

My point? Folks, please don't kid yourselves; Washington is all in on the notion that politicians, through redistribution, can take care of their cronies, contain contractions and seal the next election all at the same time. Thus, given that they believe stimulus works, the party opposing the party in the White House will forever embrace all the arguments against deficit spending and ultra-easy money. I.e., first and foremost, they want to win the next election. Of course, once they've taken over, they're suddenly (and hypocritically) all for any expansion program that promises to boost GDP---while maintaining their pretense of commitment to limited government.

Wednesday, July 17, 2013

Tuesday, July 16, 2013

I hope I'm wrong...

Bernanke tested the water a few weeks ago and found that it was far too cold to go a swimming. Since then he has told the markets what they wanted to hear: That there'll be no diving of bond prices---that is, there'll be no dousing QE into the cold water---just yet.

You see the financial markets literally own a majority in the Fed. We knew that to be the case under Greenspan, and my how we know it under Bernanke---as we witnessed shortly after CNBC'S Jim Cramer's "they know nothing" tirade. The Fed Chairman knows that if at anytime during his next two days of Congressional testimony he lets loose with the merest utterance of taper, that isn't immediately followed by the terms data-dependent and accommodative, the Dow will respond with a 200 point SAY WHAT!?! And the 10 year treasury will chime in with a 2.9% COME AGAIN!?! Which would guarantee placatory followups from every Fed Governor (even the hawks) at every lunch crowd they address for weeks to come.

So rest easy, fair trader, no worries this week (not Fed induced anyway).

As for you, staid investor, while you don't relish triple-digit declines anymore than traders do, the absolute best thing for you (as I've illustrated ad nauseam of late: here's one, here's another, and another) would be for Bernanke and company to step aside and incite another (although unattended) Cramer tantrum and a healthy pullback in asset prices.

But, alas, I don't see that happening this week. I truly hope I'm wrong...

Summers for Fed Chair? Hmm...

Dean Baker is passionately opposed to Larry Summers succeeding Ben Bernanke, as he states in his Huffington Post article The Return of Larry Summers? 

He makes his opinion crystal clear that Summers was instrumental in allowing banks (through deregulation) the freedom to ultimately take down the 2008 U.S. economy. While we can surely debate the merits of deregulation (which becomes meritless when freer banks are not free to fail), for today I'll keep it brief and focus on the following from Baker's rant:
Even more important than his role in pushing financial deregulation is the fact that Summers played a direct role in promoting the imbalances from which the economy continues to suffer. The trade deficit was relatively modest through President Clinton's first term in office, averaging just over 1 percent of GDP.

This changed dramatically in 1997 following the East Asian financial crisis. The basic story was fairly simple. The crisis knocked the fast-growing economies of the region off their feet. South Korea, Thailand, and the other economies of the region saw a massive capital flight as creditors rushed to take their money home.

The IMF, acting under the direction of then-Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin, Federal Reserve Board Chair Alan Greenspan, and Rubin's top assistant Larry Summers, agreed to a bailout, but only with harsh conditions. They required the East Asian countries to pay back their debts in full. In order for this to be possible, the currencies of the region plunged in value against the dollar. This made their goods very cheap and allowed them to hugely increase exports to the United States.

The resulting run-up of the dollar was the cause of the huge trade deficits the United States has seen over the last 15 years. The trade deficit peaked at almost 6 percent of GDP ($960 billion in today's economy) in 2006, as the over-valued dollar made U.S. goods and services less competitive in the world economy.

I've never been a Larry Summers fan, but if he indeed directed the IMF to require countries to pay back their debts, and if paying back debt is a core Summers' principle, I'd be leaning his way over the reportedly ultra-dovish frontrunner Janet Yellen.

Now, I'm a bit lost on how the "harsh" stance requiring borrowers to pay back their debts (the nerve!) plunged those nations' currencies. If memory serves, the term used in '97 was the "Asian Currency Crisis". The IMF loans were in response to conditions that had already caused the plunging. I suspect Baker means that if the IMF had simply handed the troubled nations all the unconditional capital they would ever need, creditors would've rushed back to the unreformed region, promptly propping up its currencies. I'm thinking that's a stretch.

But if he's right, and Summers' actions indeed resulted in you and I gaining the opportunity to enrich our lives by saving money on the stuff we import, and thus fostering the growth of the Samsungs, the Hyundais, and the Kias---and the innovation and the all-important competition they bring to the world---I may become a Larry Summers fan after all. 

Monday, July 15, 2013

The Butterfly Effect... (video)

My business requires me to stay in tune with the financial market narrative du jour: If only to help our clients---through my written commentary as well as during face-to-face meetings---see through the media haze and maintain what I view to be a healthy long-term perspective. As personality after personality offer up their predictions (and, thus, their portfolios' positions) through the financial networks, I find myself asking the TV; "How the heck can you possibly know that? By what magic can you know at what level the S&P will close out the year? Aren't there way too many variables?" Of course, were I actually addressing those self-anointed gurus, my questions would be purely rhetorical: I absolutely know that they absolutely cannot know. For me to believe otherwise would be detrimental to the investors who rely on our services.

With that in mind, I have re-posted below an article I wrote exactly a year ago today titled The Butterfly Effect. If you at all listen to the prognosticators, I  suspect that you can't help but wonder if maybe, just maybe, the one who claims to have forecast that we'd be precisely where we currently be has it all figured out. If so, please read the following in its entirety. I found the video to be particularly interesting:

 

THE BUTTERFLY EFFECT, July 15, 2012

I have expressed here in numerous articles my belief, I should say “the empirical truth”, that the near-term directions of economies and markets are impossible to predict. There are infinite and ever-changing variables at play. Think of a feather drifting in the breeze; the slightest invisible current can alter its direction without warning. A butterfly in India can flap its wings and set off a chain of events that will one day destroy a neighborhood in Midwestern United States. Think of seven billion individual human beings, each pursuing his and her own separate interests, each setting off chain reactions affected by invisible currents too numerous to count and too ephemeral to follow.

Economists and gurus of all stripes will (virtually) never cop to their (of course it’s everybody’s) cluelessness. For economists, it’s forever the counterfactual. The champions of fiscal stimulus told us that without the $800+ billion spending package unemployment would go north of 8%. Well, with the package, the jobless rate went north of 10%, and remains north of 8% today. Of course, to them, this only proves that we needed the stimulus even more desperately than they originally forecast. They now claim, in arrogant I-told-you-so fashion, that without it, unemployment would've gone into the teens. Shame on us for ever doubting them.

But the market gurus take the cake. They’ll make 200 guesses over 10 years, get lucky on 81, then feature one or more of those 81 in every article and ad selling their newsletter subscription, newest book or, worse (and scariest) yet, their money management services. The sad thing is, a few of these guys and gals have some decent insights to offer.  But they forever kill it with me the moment they claim to have foretold (for example) back in the early 2000s just how the last ten years would play out—as yet another (my 81 out of 200 example—who has 1.5 million subscribers to his newsletter) tried recently. I have yet to Google even one of these prognosticators  (there are newsletters that record and track their every prediction) without finding him or her to be sorely misleading (by professing predictive prowess) his or her readers. Not that the claim in question isn't valid, it’s just that for every one lucky guess I’ll discover three others where he or she entirely missed the mark. I mean think about it; if they indeed could accurately forecast anything, why the hell would they forecast it for you and me? They’d be trillionaires. And they’d confine their predictions to their own trading accounts (for their strategies wouldn't work if everyone followed them), while on their yachts sipping Dom Perignon and/or curing world hunger.

So what are we, as investors, to do? In my too-humble-to-forecast opinion we default to the cyclical nature of all things, to fundamental fiscal values and to fundamental valuations. Cyclicality, in economic terms, would be the movement between expansion and contraction—intensified or muted in both directions by man’s (our elected and appointed officials’) efforts to control nature, and, at times, by Mother Nature herself (see video). In financial markets that would be your bull and bear markets—intensified in both directions by man’s greed (tech in the 90s, real estate in the mid 00s) and by his fear (tech in the early 00s, real estate in the late 00s). Fundamental fiscal values—the values of fiscally sound families, companies and countries—come into play when we’re talking public policy: Policymakers simply can’t borrow beyond their countries’ means, centrally plan their economies and subsidize the efforts of their cronies without ultimately exacting great suffering onto those who naively voted them into office (think today’s Europe). Fundamental valuations for stocks would be the price of shares relative to earnings, earnings growth, book value, free cash flow, dividends, liquidity and interest rates. For bonds it would be simply where yields sit (historically speaking) relative to maturities and credit quality.

Today’s snapshot:

The global economy recently suffered what’s been dubbed the “Greatest Recession Since the Great Depression”. Current pace notwithstanding, I don’t suspect man has yet entirely circumvented the economic cycle. Egregiously poor public policy is playing out in Europe (shame on us here in America if we can’t recognize where they went wrong and keep from making the same mistakes). Stocks have rebounded measurably from their 2009 lows, yet valuations remain relatively (historically speaking) compelling while bond prices are trading at valuations I never imagined (prices extremely high, yields extremely low).

All that said and you’re still desperate to know: When will stock prices trade where earnings (by historical norms) would put them?  And when’s the bond bubble going to burst?

Okay you win. Against my better judgment I’ll offer my forecast, but I’ll need a little time to formulate, then get back to you. And while I’m at it I’ll figure out precisely when the next hurricane will hit the Midwest, and how the world economy will fare as seven billion personalities allocate their diverse resources in the weeks and months to come.

Friday, July 12, 2013

Induced by immediate benefits...

One of history's greatest quotes (in my humble opinion) came from one of history's greatest economists, Frederich Hayek:
The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design.

In one of my recent monetary policy rants, I picked on two self-proclaimed champions of freedom. I was reminded of them, and so many others, upon reading the last sentence of the following from Hayek's The Constitution of Liberty, which I found in Sudha R. Shenoy's collection of Hayek excerpts, A Tiger By The Tail:
It is no accident that inflationary policies are generally advocated by those who want more government control—though, unfortunately, not by them alone. The increased dependence of the individual upon government which inflation produces and the demand for more government action to which this leads may for the socialist be an argument in its favour. Those who wish to preserve freedom should recognise, however, that inflation is probably the most important single factor in that vicious circle wherein one kind of government action makes more and more government control necessary. For this reason all those who wish to stop the drift toward increasing government control should concentrate their efforts on monetary policy. There is perhaps nothing more disheartening than the fact that there are still so many intelligent and informed people who in most other respects will defend freedom and yet are induced by the immediate benefits of an expansionist policy to support what, in the long run, must destroy the foundations of a free society.