Showing posts with label the fed. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the fed. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 7, 2014

So how can the Fed hold back the economy and goose stock prices at the same time?

Allan Meltzer, in today's Wall Street Journal, like so many others, credits the Fed for this remarkable bull run in stocks:
Ironically, despite often repeated demands for increased redistribution to favor middle- and lower-income groups, the policies pursued by the Obama administration and supported by the Federal Reserve have accomplished the opposite. When the president campaigns in the midterm election, he will talk about the relative gains by the 1%. Voters should recognize that goosing the stock market through very low interest rates, not to mention the subsidies and handouts to cronies, have contributed to that result.

Earlier in his column he writes:
The Fed's unprecedented quantitative easing since 2008 failed to lead to a robust recovery. The unemployment rate has gradually declined, but the main reason is that workers have withdrawn from the labor force. The stock market boomed, bringing support from traders, but the rise in asset prices of equities didn't stimulate growth by inducing investment in new capital. Investment continues to be sluggish.

Now, I'm all in with Meltzer in terms of the ill-conceived policies of today's powers that be. But, frankly, I struggle with the tired line about the stock market gains being all about Fed "goosing".

Think about it: As Meltzer rightly states, "the Fed's unprecedented quantitative easing since 2008 failed to lead to a robust recovery." Far from it in fact. Yet, the stock market "boomed". The notion that the stock market would in fact "boom", or, I should say, continue to "boom" (as it can certainly "boom" in anticipation of a robust recovery), amid a most tepid economic recovery, frankly, makes no sense. The it's-all-about-the-Fed crowd never seem to mention record corporate earnings when they talk about record quantitative easing. I don't suppose, therefore, that they're crediting---at least not entirely---quantitative easing for record corporate profits.

So when Electronic Arts reports blowout earnings (yesterday) and the stock price jumps 14% in the after market, does the it's-all-about-the-Fed crowd stand up and say "see, QE is goosing stock prices"? I certainly hope not. Or when Amazon's stock plunges 10% (last Friday) on disappointing numbers, or Ford's is down 3%+ (last Friday) for its uninspiring performance, well, what about them apples? I mean if it's all about the Fed, earnings disappointments should be brushed off amid Yellen's promise to keep rates low way into the foreseeable future. Oh, and speaking of apples, Apple blew away top and bottom line estimates and its stock price rewarded shareholders handsomely as a result. Was that all about the Fed?

Regular readers know that I largely share Meltzer's view that the Fed, in its efforts to be the be all and end all for the economy, is playing a very dangerous game. And I'm warming up to the idea that while "accommodation" is the Fed's description of present policy, tighter regulations, along with the interest it now pays banks on their excess reserves, is anything but accommodative. Meaning, Fed actions may after all be, in fact, holding the economy back. But if that's the case, you'd almost have to conclude that the Fed is holding back the stock market as well (could the market be even higher were it not for the Fed?). Which is opposite the case being made by many of the folks, like Meltzer, who believe the Fed is holding back the economy. Hmm...

Lastly, just to get in front of an email or two from anyone who would point to my seeming naiveté, I'll, in bullet point fashion, answer the question I ask in the title:

How can the Fed goose stock prices?

  • By killing the stock market's competition by keeping interest rates extremely low.

  • By boosting corporate profits by lowering borrowing costs.

  • Conventional wisdom says P/Es should be higher when interest rates are lower. Therefore, keeping interest rates very low permits very high stock prices.

  • Investors who believe that the Fed will ultimately succeed in boosting the economy will bid stocks higher in anticipation---during this period of "accommodation".


I'm sure if I think harder I could add another one or two, but it's getting late.

Aside from the second point---which by itself is insufficient---none of the above explain how the Fed might be boosting corporate earnings (well, I guess you could argue the fourth point, should they succeed, as well). And, at the end of the day, when the price of your average share of stock trades at a multiple above earnings that is consistent with the long-term average, the it's-all-about-the-Fed argument---in that it can't explain record earnings---loses its steam. Otherwise stocks, in the aggregate, would be trading at multiples that would have folks exiting the market like it's 1999.  

Now, all that said, it would not surprise me in the least to see the stock market contract when the Fed finally embarks on its quest to rein in what it's done over the past few years. Which simply means that while the Fed, in my view, does not deserve the credit for this bull market, it could very well earn some of the blame for ultimately ending it...

Tuesday, July 16, 2013

I hope I'm wrong...

Bernanke tested the water a few weeks ago and found that it was far too cold to go a swimming. Since then he has told the markets what they wanted to hear: That there'll be no diving of bond prices---that is, there'll be no dousing QE into the cold water---just yet.

You see the financial markets literally own a majority in the Fed. We knew that to be the case under Greenspan, and my how we know it under Bernanke---as we witnessed shortly after CNBC'S Jim Cramer's "they know nothing" tirade. The Fed Chairman knows that if at anytime during his next two days of Congressional testimony he lets loose with the merest utterance of taper, that isn't immediately followed by the terms data-dependent and accommodative, the Dow will respond with a 200 point SAY WHAT!?! And the 10 year treasury will chime in with a 2.9% COME AGAIN!?! Which would guarantee placatory followups from every Fed Governor (even the hawks) at every lunch crowd they address for weeks to come.

So rest easy, fair trader, no worries this week (not Fed induced anyway).

As for you, staid investor, while you don't relish triple-digit declines anymore than traders do, the absolute best thing for you (as I've illustrated ad nauseam of late: here's one, here's another, and another) would be for Bernanke and company to step aside and incite another (although unattended) Cramer tantrum and a healthy pullback in asset prices.

But, alas, I don't see that happening this week. I truly hope I'm wrong...

Friday, July 5, 2013

I'd love to say I told you so about bonds....

Of course I'd love to say I told you so about bonds (getting hammered as I type), but being dead wrong on my bearish call for 3 years does not afford me the hubris to pretend I can time markets. Those of you who pay me to handle your stuff know that I have been, nonetheless, unapologetic in my subjecting your fixed-income allocation to subpar relative (to what we're used to) results. The thing is, the risk/reward relationship has been grossly out of whack when it comes to the bond market. I.e., the upside is minimal (below 2% until recently on 10 year money) while the downside has been monstrous (imagine what a sub-2% bond is worth when interest rates are rising). In other words, when interest rates are at history-of-mankind-lows there's very little room for price appreciation---and huge room for price depreciation---in an investment-grade (or otherwise) bond portfolio.

Of course if this (rising yields and falling prices) keeps up, there'll be opportunities to once again bring some yield into your fixed income allocation that we will want to carefully (remember bonds are supposed to be a stable part of your portfolio) exploit.

Stay tuned...

Sunday, June 30, 2013

Add one to Krugman's "Always Wrong Club"

Paul Krugman cleverly dubbed the likes of John Taylor, Niall Ferguson and 21 other economists who warned, back in 2010, of potential dire consequences resulting from quantitative easing, the "Always Wrong Club" (the title of his yesterday's blogpost). Well, looks like the club needs to induct one more member, Krugman himself.

Here he is sharing his wisdom on the bond market to New York Times readers back on May 9th:
 Why, then, all the talk of a bond bubble? Partly it reflects the correct observation that interest rates are very low by historical standards. What you need to bear in mind, however, is that the economy is also in especially terrible shape by historical standards — once-in-three-generations terrible. The usual rules about what constitutes a reasonable level of interest rates don’t apply.

There’s also, one has to say, an element of wishful thinking here. For whatever reason, many people in the financial industry have developed a deep hatred for Ben Bernanke, the Fed chairman, and everything he does; they want his easy-money policies ended, and they also want to see those policies fail in some spectacular fashion. As it turns out, however, dislike for bearded Princeton professors is not a good basis for investment strategy.

And one should never forget the example of Japan, where bets against government bonds — justified by more or less the same arguments currently made to justify claims of a U.S. bond bubble — ended in grief so often that the whole trade came to be known as the “widow maker.” At this point, Japan’s debt is well over twice its G.D.P., its budget deficit remains large, and the interest rate on 10-year bonds is 0.6 percent. No, that’s not a misprint.

All in all, the case for significant bubbles in stocks or, especially, bonds is weak. And that conclusion matters for policy as well as investment.

You know, I happen to be in the financial industry and I promise you, I hold no hatred whatsoever for Ben Bernanke. Not even close! I'm sure he believes he's doing the right things; the fact that I disagree in no way suggests that I hate the man. And, please, make no mistake---while there are no doubt a few frustrated shorts out there---the last thing in the world "many people in the financial industry" want is Bernanke's policies to "fail in some spectacular fashion". Talk about cutting off your nose to spite your face!

As for investment strategies and the proclamations of bearded Princeton professors, well, let's see; Bernanke made his "Great Moderation" speech (a promise of economic smoothing attributed largely to sound monetary policy) in February 2004, just shy of four years before the onset of the worst recession since the Great Depression. OOPS! As for the bearded Princeton professor Krugman of May 9th, he would have his readers give nary a thought to a selloff in the bond market. OOPS!

And here's Krugman today suggesting that the other bearded Princeton professor "grossly misunderstood" the nature of the relationship between his statements and market expectations. Yet (big surprise) nowhere will he admit that, per his May 9 article, he grossly misunderstands markets in general:
Bond prices have plunged, and the Fed’s attempts to inform markets that they’ve got it all wrong have only modestly mitigated the impact.

What went wrong? The Fed grossly misunderstood the nature of the relationship between its statements and market expectations. It believed that the market was listening closely to the details of what it said. In fact, the market doesn’t — and probably shouldn’t. Instead, it listens to the tone of Fed statements, and also Fed actions; it’s more a matter of character judgment than mathematics. And what the Fed conveyed with the tapering talk was a sense that its heart really isn’t in this stimulus thing.

Bottom line folks; there are a few things in life that you just don't do. Such as:

Pee into the wind.
Lick a frozen lamp post.
Spit straight up.
Eat prunes when you're hungry.
Stand between a dog and a fire hydrant.
Take investment advice from bearded Princeton professors.
BUY BONDS WHEN INTEREST RATES ARE AT ALL TIME LOWS!!!!!!!!!!

Saturday, June 29, 2013

The Great Distortion...

"To me Ben Bernanke is a great American hero", said once treasury secretary/Bernanke abettor Hank Paulson last week in a CNBC television interview. Like Superman saving the Earth from a rogue asteroid, the mild-mannered leader of the U.S. Central Bank turned man-of-steel in the eleventh hour and rescued us from ..... uh ..... what? The greatest recession since the Great Depression? Nope! That's precisely what occurred. Yet, according to Paulson, our greatest-recession-since-the-Great-Depression-experience was some super-human (or humane) monetary policy achievement. Bernanke, he proclaimed, saved us from the Next Great Depression. I strongly suspect that had we experienced the Next Great Depression, Paulson would herald Bernanke as the great American hero who rescued us from a Depression Greater than the Next Great Depression. Truly, there's no trough that can't be buoyed by a well-articulated counterfactual.

Okay, let's be fair, the greatest recession since the Great Depression indeed bottomed amid mammoth monetary stimulus, as did the stock market (after the major averages plunged some 50%). So did Bernanke save us from, say, a deeper bottom and, say, a 60% plunge in stocks? 70% maybe? Hmm.... I wonder what would've happened without the mammoth stimulus? Surely the economy would've bottomed, but sooner? Later? Deeper? As deeply? Surely the stock market would have bottomed as well, but sooner? Later? Deeper? As deeply? We can counterfactual till the cows come home but we'll never know the dates nor the depths. And we'll never know for sure whether central planners extinguished or exacerbated the Great Recession.

The Keynesian-hearted will credit the slightest growth to policy. The free-market-minded blame our historically-slight recovery on policy-induced uncertainty. What both sides should (but won't) agree on is that a great distortion in the pricing of bonds has resulted from Bernanke's (perceived) super-humane efforts. The question now is how will the markets ultimately correct this great distortion? And did last week offer up a sneak preview? Time will tell...

Monday, April 5, 2010

Doing Unto Others

So your seventh-grader comes home from school today and tells you how much she loved playing cross-fire (dodgeball to you/me) in P.E. because she hit Tyler smack in the face. Shocked at the sadistic nature of your little angel

Monday, October 19, 2009

Minnie Mouse, the Market, and the Dollar

Picture 007Is this seven month stock market rally the real deal? Does Dow 10,000 reflect improved corporate earnings, a rebounding economy, record low interest rates and trillions of sideline cash? Or, is it no more legitimate than the current homerun record?

The doubters tell us that the market