As you may know, my work requires that I pay attention to the opinions of those who---I have to assume based on the audience they attract---know what they're talking about when it comes to the financial markets and the world economy. Having done what I do for a very long time, it has become abundantly clear that even the presumed "best" in the business can be every bit as much the victims, or the beneficiaries, of their ideologies as the rest of us.
My advice to you, dear reader, when it comes to the opinions of "the rest of us"---that would be your family, friends, office mates and neighbors---is to dismiss the opinions of those with the strongest opinions. Pardon my seeming condescension, but the fist-pounders tend to be the faithful parrots of the personalities who, for example, appear on the only cable TV news network they're willing to watch.
As for the opinions of the "experts" who attract wide audiences, my advice is to dismiss the opinions of those who sound like they know precisely what they're talking about. For they are generally the ones with the strongest one-dimensional convictions. And when we're talking about the global markets, and economy, we're talking about ever-evolving structures with moving parts too numerous to even begin to aggregate, let alone anticipate.
That'll be my segue to today's message:
Yesterday, I performed my semi-monthly valuation analysis of sectors, styles, market caps, non-US developed and emerging markets. As I've been reporting, I don't characterize the overall market as cheap, like I did in early 2013. However, I don't see it---historically-speaking---as expensive either. Broken out by sectors, styles, regions and size, I do find areas that look relatively expensive, a couple that look relatively cheap, and many in the middle. The 18,000-point (as in Dow points) question is, what are corporate earnings going to do going forward? Should they rise from here, all else equal, stocks should continue their climb. Should they decline, all else equal, so should stock prices. The problem is the "all else"---it never stays equal.
So, what would be the "all else"? Well, it's a lot of things---and it's different things to different people. For me (in no particular order) it's the bond market, interest rates, cap-ex spending (business expansion), GDP, the Fed, the Eurozone, the ECB, the UK, the Bank of England, China, the Bank of China, Japan, the Bank of Japan, the emerging markets, retail sales, housing, demographic trends, producer prices, consumer prices, small business sentiment, investor sentiment, commodities prices, short interest (how many are betting big on a drop), margin debt (how many are betting big on a rally), stock sector valuations and 200 day moving averages---and that's the short list. And it's way too much to cover in one blog post.
So here's my plan for the next few weeks: Starting today with bonds, I'm going to offer up a brief---succinct as possible---synopsis, one a day (or so), on each of the above. My aim is to help you put what you're hearing from your favorite news source into what I view is a healthy perspective, and---more importantly---to help you understand how the "all else" (or some of the "all else") can impact your portfolio. As I go along, you'll understand why I prefaced this exercise the way I did. Here goes:
BONDS (AND INTEREST RATES): The Basics: The thing to keep in mind about bonds is that the price an investor pays and the interest rate received move inversely to one another. Using treasury bonds as an example: When the federal government runs a budget deficit and, therefore, must borrow (issue treasury bonds) to pay its bills, investor appetite determines how much the government will have to pay in interest. If the interest rate environment is such that high quality debt is paying, say, 4% annually for a 10 year term, the U.S. Treasury will to be forced to offer a comparable yield on 10 year treasury bonds to attract investors. Rising interest rates---with regard to high quality bonds---generally occur during periods of rising optimism over the prospects for economic growth, or a prevailing fear of higher inflation.
As you may know, the 10 year treasury trades today at a remarkably low 2.54%. So, what does that say about the prospects for the economy? Well, based on what you just read, nothing good. And, indeed, that may be what today's very low yield is telling us about the future. Although, it could also be telling us something else. Below I'll list a few possibilities and their reasonings...
Yields offered by other sovereign issuers are comparable---to lower---than the safer U.S Treasury bond: For example, Germany's 10yr currently yields around 1.3%, France's 1.8%, and Spain's 2.8%. According to CNBC's Rick Santelli, the world's central banks' gobbling up of so much government debt has lessened the global supply relative to demand---making such debt more expensive and, therefore, lower yielding...
Geopolitical angst: Today that means fear over Russia's foray into the Ukraine. Should that conflict lead to serious trade disruptions (think Russia not supplying energy to Germany, etc.), there'll be economic headwinds the world economy doesn't need at the moment. Nervous investors might indeed buy treasuries as a safe port till the storm blows over.
Currency manipulation: There's always that game countries play (while denying it the whole time) to goose their exports (and, in some cases, to inflate away their debt). Converting their own currency to dollars (buying treasuries) lowers its relative value against the dollar and makes their goods more attractive to U.S. consumers.
Pension fund rebalancing: This one's been featured a lot in the press lately and, frankly, I'm not entirely buying it. It goes like this: Pension funds made huge gains last year and came a long way in terms of fixing their highly advertised underfunding issues. Having done so well last year in stocks, they're locking in those profits by selling and moving huge amounts into the safe haven of the ten-year treasury bond.
It's not that I'm not buying the rebalancing story (we've been consistently selling back to equity targets throughout this bull market), it's the buying the treasury bond part. I just can't see investment consultants recommending that their pension clients buy a security at a valuation that offers far greater downside than it does upside risk. We're certainly not rebalancing our pension clients into ten-year treasuries these days.
Huge short interest: Warning! This one's a bit wonky: Every economist in a recent CNBC survey anticipated that interest rates will rise in 2014. Bond traders galore believed the same thing coming into the year. And it made perfect sense: if the economy gains some traction this year, which is (or was) widely expected, surely bond yields will rise---perhaps in a big way. So, if everybody heading into this year was thinking interest rates would rise, how is it that, as of today, they've fallen to last October lows. Wouldn't all those bears sell bonds in anticipation, thus making the rise in interest rates a self-fulfilling prophecy? Well, yeah, but remember, the Fed, foreigners, yield-seekers and fradeycats have all been buying. Plus, the federal budget deficit is about a trillion less than it was a couple of years ago, which means the government doesn't need to issue nearly as many treasury bonds in order to pay its bills---which means less supply. In essence, there have been plenty of buyers to buy up what the bears have been selling---and some.
Now, to compound matters, there's that "short interest": When you're savvy (and gutsy), and you're certain the price of a security is fixin to fall, you "short" it (borrow it [through your broker] then sell it, expecting to buy it back later at a lower price and replace it---pocketing the difference), or you short the exchange traded funds (ETFs) that invest in it, or you short its futures contracts, or you buy put options on the ETFs that invest in it (I'll stop there). When we're talking bonds, you're expecting to hit a grand slam with such strategies when interest rates spike and bond prices tank. Oh, but if you're wrong, and the price moves higher instead, you get creamed. If the price moves way higher, you get way creamed. So, when the price moves against your position, and, in the case of bonds, you fear a 1.50% handle on the ten year treasury, you---in the case of shorting---cover your shorts (buy back those bonds at a higher price than you sold them for) and lose the difference. And of course all that short covering (buying) serves to exacerbate the upward momentum in bond prices and the downward momentum in interest rates.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
While listening to a Bloomberg radio interview replay last evening---the topic being the bond market---I began to wonder if we're not about to come full circle. The guest was explaining pretty much what I've been hearing from a hoard of "experts" over the past few days; "that everybody's been wrong about bonds". "That the year's half over and, contrary to what everybody thought would occur, interest rates have been going nowhere but down---and that's where they're staying for the balance of this year."
Now, if you believe, as I do, that when an opinion starts to become crowded---when a strong consensus builds---opportunities emerge on those roads less traveled (where the crowd ain't), you expect that the bond market may soon be sending those "experts"---who are predicting low interest rates as far as their eyes can see---straight to their optometrists. In other words: should this downward move in yields make converts out of all those bears---if they finally capitulate and join the bulls---that (once the piling-in rally subsides) is when I suspect we'll see interest rates finally begin to spike and bond prices to fall---which is when you and I will, at last, find opportunities to add bonds to our portfolios.
As for those fist-pounding "experts"---the one's on TV and the one in the cubicle next to yours---if they believe today's low interest rates are 100% about the sluggish economy, they very likely possess a strong political conviction (doesn't mean they're wrong btw). As for me, I believe it's a combination of the above. I mean, surely, some are buying out of fear over the economy, some because treasury yields are higher than German bund yields, some because they're anxious about the Ukraine, some because they're trying to cheapen their home currency, some (few, let's hope) because they're rebalancing their pension portfolios, and some because they're bailing out of their short positions.
As for bonds and the stock market, the question is, how will stocks hold up when bond prices finally begin to come down? Good question!
I'll be back...
Showing posts with label bonds. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bonds. Show all posts
Thursday, May 15, 2014
Friday, July 5, 2013
I'd love to say I told you so about bonds....
Of course I'd love to say I told you so about bonds (getting hammered as I type), but being dead wrong on my bearish call for 3 years does not afford me the hubris to pretend I can time markets. Those of you who pay me to handle your stuff know that I have been, nonetheless, unapologetic in my subjecting your fixed-income allocation to subpar relative (to what we're used to) results. The thing is, the risk/reward relationship has been grossly out of whack when it comes to the bond market. I.e., the upside is minimal (below 2% until recently on 10 year money) while the downside has been monstrous (imagine what a sub-2% bond is worth when interest rates are rising). In other words, when interest rates are at history-of-mankind-lows there's very little room for price appreciation---and huge room for price depreciation---in an investment-grade (or otherwise) bond portfolio.
Of course if this (rising yields and falling prices) keeps up, there'll be opportunities to once again bring some yield into your fixed income allocation that we will want to carefully (remember bonds are supposed to be a stable part of your portfolio) exploit.
Stay tuned...
Of course if this (rising yields and falling prices) keeps up, there'll be opportunities to once again bring some yield into your fixed income allocation that we will want to carefully (remember bonds are supposed to be a stable part of your portfolio) exploit.
Stay tuned...
Sunday, June 30, 2013
Add one to Krugman's "Always Wrong Club"
Paul Krugman cleverly dubbed the likes of John Taylor, Niall Ferguson and 21 other economists who warned, back in 2010, of potential dire consequences resulting from quantitative easing, the "Always Wrong Club" (the title of his yesterday's blogpost). Well, looks like the club needs to induct one more member, Krugman himself.
Here he is sharing his wisdom on the bond market to New York Times readers back on May 9th:
You know, I happen to be in the financial industry and I promise you, I hold no hatred whatsoever for Ben Bernanke. Not even close! I'm sure he believes he's doing the right things; the fact that I disagree in no way suggests that I hate the man. And, please, make no mistake---while there are no doubt a few frustrated shorts out there---the last thing in the world "many people in the financial industry" want is Bernanke's policies to "fail in some spectacular fashion". Talk about cutting off your nose to spite your face!
As for investment strategies and the proclamations of bearded Princeton professors, well, let's see; Bernanke made his "Great Moderation" speech (a promise of economic smoothing attributed largely to sound monetary policy) in February 2004, just shy of four years before the onset of the worst recession since the Great Depression. OOPS! As for the bearded Princeton professor Krugman of May 9th, he would have his readers give nary a thought to a selloff in the bond market. OOPS!
And here's Krugman today suggesting that the other bearded Princeton professor "grossly misunderstood" the nature of the relationship between his statements and market expectations. Yet (big surprise) nowhere will he admit that, per his May 9 article, he grossly misunderstands markets in general:
Bottom line folks; there are a few things in life that you just don't do. Such as:
Pee into the wind.
Lick a frozen lamp post.
Spit straight up.
Eat prunes when you're hungry.
Stand between a dog and a fire hydrant.
Take investment advice from bearded Princeton professors.
BUY BONDS WHEN INTEREST RATES ARE AT ALL TIME LOWS!!!!!!!!!!
Here he is sharing his wisdom on the bond market to New York Times readers back on May 9th:
Why, then, all the talk of a bond bubble? Partly it reflects the correct observation that interest rates are very low by historical standards. What you need to bear in mind, however, is that the economy is also in especially terrible shape by historical standards — once-in-three-generations terrible. The usual rules about what constitutes a reasonable level of interest rates don’t apply.
There’s also, one has to say, an element of wishful thinking here. For whatever reason, many people in the financial industry have developed a deep hatred for Ben Bernanke, the Fed chairman, and everything he does; they want his easy-money policies ended, and they also want to see those policies fail in some spectacular fashion. As it turns out, however, dislike for bearded Princeton professors is not a good basis for investment strategy.
And one should never forget the example of Japan, where bets against government bonds — justified by more or less the same arguments currently made to justify claims of a U.S. bond bubble — ended in grief so often that the whole trade came to be known as the “widow maker.” At this point, Japan’s debt is well over twice its G.D.P., its budget deficit remains large, and the interest rate on 10-year bonds is 0.6 percent. No, that’s not a misprint.
All in all, the case for significant bubbles in stocks or, especially, bonds is weak. And that conclusion matters for policy as well as investment.
You know, I happen to be in the financial industry and I promise you, I hold no hatred whatsoever for Ben Bernanke. Not even close! I'm sure he believes he's doing the right things; the fact that I disagree in no way suggests that I hate the man. And, please, make no mistake---while there are no doubt a few frustrated shorts out there---the last thing in the world "many people in the financial industry" want is Bernanke's policies to "fail in some spectacular fashion". Talk about cutting off your nose to spite your face!
As for investment strategies and the proclamations of bearded Princeton professors, well, let's see; Bernanke made his "Great Moderation" speech (a promise of economic smoothing attributed largely to sound monetary policy) in February 2004, just shy of four years before the onset of the worst recession since the Great Depression. OOPS! As for the bearded Princeton professor Krugman of May 9th, he would have his readers give nary a thought to a selloff in the bond market. OOPS!
And here's Krugman today suggesting that the other bearded Princeton professor "grossly misunderstood" the nature of the relationship between his statements and market expectations. Yet (big surprise) nowhere will he admit that, per his May 9 article, he grossly misunderstands markets in general:
Bond prices have plunged, and the Fed’s attempts to inform markets that they’ve got it all wrong have only modestly mitigated the impact.
What went wrong? The Fed grossly misunderstood the nature of the relationship between its statements and market expectations. It believed that the market was listening closely to the details of what it said. In fact, the market doesn’t — and probably shouldn’t. Instead, it listens to the tone of Fed statements, and also Fed actions; it’s more a matter of character judgment than mathematics. And what the Fed conveyed with the tapering talk was a sense that its heart really isn’t in this stimulus thing.
Bottom line folks; there are a few things in life that you just don't do. Such as:
Pee into the wind.
Lick a frozen lamp post.
Spit straight up.
Eat prunes when you're hungry.
Stand between a dog and a fire hydrant.
Take investment advice from bearded Princeton professors.
BUY BONDS WHEN INTEREST RATES ARE AT ALL TIME LOWS!!!!!!!!!!
Monday, April 5, 2010
Doing Unto Others
Labels:
abuse of political power,
asset allocation,
bond market,
bonds,
capital gains,
dividends,
economy,
estate planning,
finance,
interest rates,
investing,
securities,
smoot-hawley,
Stock Market,
stocks,
tariffs,
the fed,
the federal reserve,
trade
Monday, November 2, 2009
Is The Rally Over or Is a New Bull Market Just Underway?
Monday, September 28, 2009
The Great Tree: Chapter 2
As the years unfolded in the land of the Great Tree the people grew by legions and their lives grew complicated. The wise foretold of a coming day when the number of mouths to feed would far exceed, in spite of man’s intervention, the Great Tree’s ability to sustain them. Fear gripped the hearts of all the people – yet even the threat of famine deterred not the gluttons (those who would not store) from consuming every morsel they could gather.
It was therefore declared that for the good of the community and the survival of the Tree, those desiring to pioneer beyond the shelter and create orchards of their own, would be allowed to do so and retain the bounty of their harvests for themselves and their families.
The majority of those eager to venture beyond the shade however, given their history, would not trust their leaders’ intent. They feared their farms would ultimately be subject to the government’s confiscatory practices. Yet, in spite of all historic precedent, and in the face of an otherwise dire fate, their leader’s aims were indeed virtuous.
As necessity then dictated, to inspire the people’s trust and to advance an entrepreneurial spirit, a new constitution, guaranteeing certain inalienable rights and protecting every citizen’s freedom to work and produce on his own behalf, was drafted and unanimously ratified. The old leaders stepped down as new officials, sworn to defend and enforce the covenants set forth in the constitution (its authors in fact), were duly elected by the people.
So it came to pass that those willing to dirty their hands, to extract the seeds from the fruit of the Great Tree, dig the holes, sow the seeds, water and fertilize the soil and ultimately profit from their own harvests, would be free to leave the shade of their once Great Giver in favor of their own bountiful orchards – conditioned only upon the paying of a small duty to the government. This duty amounted to a modest percentage of their annual yield and would fund the enforcement of the rules of law that protected their rights to build the lives of their dreams, as well as provide for certain essential services to the greater community.
While there were indeed many of the Land’s people who found satisfaction in these pursuits, there remained others however who possessed not the desire to produce their own good fortune, who chose instead to continue to live on whatever the Great Tree would bestow upon them.
Henceforth, while the industrious ones no longer needed to take from the Tree’s limbs, her bounty was sufficient to continue to feed those too old, unable, and even those unwilling to work, for some time to come. As the years passed however, the shade beneath her leaves grew crowded once again. Crowded by men and women who lacked either the capacity or the desire to venture beyond the great canopy to provide for themselves.
As the division in terms of the quality of life among those who strove for better and those who did not widened, a distinct envy began to develop among the self-proclaimed have-nots toward the strivers. The shade-dwellers would contend that, although (except for the disabled) their lot was clearly the result of their lack of initiative, the system was somehow unfair. That there simply should not be such a division, that in the interest of the social good, all manner of men should enjoy an equal share of the Earth’s bounty without regard to their contribution to the production and harvesting of such.
As the shade-dwelling masses grew, their influence upon the once great government grew strong. For all manner of men, pioneers and shade-seekers alike were rightfully endowed with the right to vote. And as the powers (and personal benefits) of political office were expanded, the position of policymaker became a highly coveted one indeed. So much so that the men and women campaigning for these positions would, regardless of their own ideals, cater to the group(s) they believed possessed the requisite votes to win them their desired posts.
And so it came to pass that a new era was born, an era where political gain took precedent over the legitimate needs of a growing society, and the shade-dwellers, now great in number, became a most powerful political force. Prospective politicians would stand within the crowded shelter of the Great Tree and pledge that while in office; they would increase taxation on those who, by virtue of their hard work and creativity, enjoyed lifestyles beyond what the shade-dwellers could ever imagine. As if the very spirit that once saved their land from ruin, could now be deemed selfish, greedy and deserving of punishment through excessive taxation.
Henceforth, under the guise of fairness, the self-interested politicians would commit their efforts to the redistribution of the land’s wealth and yes, the confiscated booty would be distributed among those who, by contributing nothing more than their votes, were deemed deserving of such.
The workers, the entrepreneurs, the pioneers who dared to risk going beyond the shade to build a better life, and to relieve the Tree of her burden, were perplexed by the chastisement being brought to bear upon them. The rule of law that once made possible and promoted their efforts had, at the hands of the politically ambitious, been manipulated and indeed corrupted to the point where the more successful their labors, the disproportionately greater the duties (taxes, regulatory fees, licenses, etc. etc.) they would be forced to pay. They had become villains. In the government’s eyes they had enjoyed too much success and would hence pay dearly for their perceived sins.
Law abiding as they were, the industrious, while they disagreed in principle, would nonetheless pay the higher taxes and fees levied against them. Yet they remained keenly aware of two fundamental truths; that they, not the policymakers, were responsible for the success of their great society, and that the maintaining of their personal liberties would lie, as perhaps never before, in their own hands.. And they knew therefore that a great day of reckoning was soon to come.
It was therefore declared that for the good of the community and the survival of the Tree, those desiring to pioneer beyond the shelter and create orchards of their own, would be allowed to do so and retain the bounty of their harvests for themselves and their families.
The majority of those eager to venture beyond the shade however, given their history, would not trust their leaders’ intent. They feared their farms would ultimately be subject to the government’s confiscatory practices. Yet, in spite of all historic precedent, and in the face of an otherwise dire fate, their leader’s aims were indeed virtuous.
As necessity then dictated, to inspire the people’s trust and to advance an entrepreneurial spirit, a new constitution, guaranteeing certain inalienable rights and protecting every citizen’s freedom to work and produce on his own behalf, was drafted and unanimously ratified. The old leaders stepped down as new officials, sworn to defend and enforce the covenants set forth in the constitution (its authors in fact), were duly elected by the people.
So it came to pass that those willing to dirty their hands, to extract the seeds from the fruit of the Great Tree, dig the holes, sow the seeds, water and fertilize the soil and ultimately profit from their own harvests, would be free to leave the shade of their once Great Giver in favor of their own bountiful orchards – conditioned only upon the paying of a small duty to the government. This duty amounted to a modest percentage of their annual yield and would fund the enforcement of the rules of law that protected their rights to build the lives of their dreams, as well as provide for certain essential services to the greater community.
While there were indeed many of the Land’s people who found satisfaction in these pursuits, there remained others however who possessed not the desire to produce their own good fortune, who chose instead to continue to live on whatever the Great Tree would bestow upon them.
Henceforth, while the industrious ones no longer needed to take from the Tree’s limbs, her bounty was sufficient to continue to feed those too old, unable, and even those unwilling to work, for some time to come. As the years passed however, the shade beneath her leaves grew crowded once again. Crowded by men and women who lacked either the capacity or the desire to venture beyond the great canopy to provide for themselves.
As the division in terms of the quality of life among those who strove for better and those who did not widened, a distinct envy began to develop among the self-proclaimed have-nots toward the strivers. The shade-dwellers would contend that, although (except for the disabled) their lot was clearly the result of their lack of initiative, the system was somehow unfair. That there simply should not be such a division, that in the interest of the social good, all manner of men should enjoy an equal share of the Earth’s bounty without regard to their contribution to the production and harvesting of such.
As the shade-dwelling masses grew, their influence upon the once great government grew strong. For all manner of men, pioneers and shade-seekers alike were rightfully endowed with the right to vote. And as the powers (and personal benefits) of political office were expanded, the position of policymaker became a highly coveted one indeed. So much so that the men and women campaigning for these positions would, regardless of their own ideals, cater to the group(s) they believed possessed the requisite votes to win them their desired posts.
And so it came to pass that a new era was born, an era where political gain took precedent over the legitimate needs of a growing society, and the shade-dwellers, now great in number, became a most powerful political force. Prospective politicians would stand within the crowded shelter of the Great Tree and pledge that while in office; they would increase taxation on those who, by virtue of their hard work and creativity, enjoyed lifestyles beyond what the shade-dwellers could ever imagine. As if the very spirit that once saved their land from ruin, could now be deemed selfish, greedy and deserving of punishment through excessive taxation.
Henceforth, under the guise of fairness, the self-interested politicians would commit their efforts to the redistribution of the land’s wealth and yes, the confiscated booty would be distributed among those who, by contributing nothing more than their votes, were deemed deserving of such.
The workers, the entrepreneurs, the pioneers who dared to risk going beyond the shade to build a better life, and to relieve the Tree of her burden, were perplexed by the chastisement being brought to bear upon them. The rule of law that once made possible and promoted their efforts had, at the hands of the politically ambitious, been manipulated and indeed corrupted to the point where the more successful their labors, the disproportionately greater the duties (taxes, regulatory fees, licenses, etc. etc.) they would be forced to pay. They had become villains. In the government’s eyes they had enjoyed too much success and would hence pay dearly for their perceived sins.
Law abiding as they were, the industrious, while they disagreed in principle, would nonetheless pay the higher taxes and fees levied against them. Yet they remained keenly aware of two fundamental truths; that they, not the policymakers, were responsible for the success of their great society, and that the maintaining of their personal liberties would lie, as perhaps never before, in their own hands.. And they knew therefore that a great day of reckoning was soon to come.
Monday, September 21, 2009
We Have Nothing to Fear but the Lack of Fear Itself
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)